Editorials Reviews Previews Essays Worth Playing

Essays

Essays 07 January 2020, 18:43

The Witcher from Netflix vs The Witcher 3 - We Compare Sapkowski's Adaptations

After the premiere of the Netflix Witcher we woke up in a world where we have two adaptations of Andrzej Sapkowski's books that have gained international fame and recognition. We try to compare them applying different criteria.

Table of Contents

Slavic themes

And here, again, the first episode – this time showing a village. Like one from Gothic 3. - The Witcher from Netflix vs The Witcher 3 – We Compare Sapkowski's Adaptations - dokument - 2020-01-07
And here, again, the first episode – this time showing a village. Like one from Gothic 3.

A kind of bonus and the icing on the cake. No, we do not claim that Witcher adaptations must necessarily have Slavic character – but we decided to include it here nonetheless. So how is it? I'll spoil it for you: the game wins. The Witcher 3 has Slavic rural landscapes in Velen, Slavic features of peasant culture, Slavic origins of proper names. Remember the Pellar's quests? Or the quest on the Fyke Isle (the tower, whose owner was eaten by mice?) – both very Slav.

These additions made The Wild Hunt expressive and unique. The same cannot unfortunately be said about the universe shown in the series. Here, Netflix shows generic fantasy land, which tries to imitate the gloominess of Westeros from GoT so hard that it forgets to create its own identity. In fact, this depiction feels like it can't even fully decide whether it belongs to low or high fantasy – on the one hand, we have poor villages where worldly life takes place, on the other hand, there are places like Aretuza.

I appreciate the fact that original names (such as Jaskier) were preserved, though! This is indeed a nice decision from Hissrich. You can feel a kind of perverse pleasure listening to Jodhi Mai (Calanthe) cripple her tongue trying to spell the name Chociebuz, and Henry Cavill combats alien consonants every time he addresses Jaskier (rather than Dandelion!). A trifle, but pleasant.

THE VOTE IN THE OFFICE

Without surprises – 84.2% recognized the game to be more Slavic than the series (the vast majority voting "definitely").

Which was more Slavic?

Christopher Mysiak

Christopher Mysiak

Associated with GRYOnline.pl since 2013, first as a co-worker, and since 2017 - a member of the Editorial team. Currently the head of the Game Encyclopedia. His older brother - a game collector and player - sparked his interest in electronic entertainment. He got an education as a librarian/infobroker - but he did not follow in the footsteps of Deckard Cain or the Shadow Broker. Before he moved from Krakow to Poznan in 2020, he was remembered for attending Tolkien conventions, owning a Subaru Impreza, and swinging a sword in the company's parking lot.

more

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

The Witcher 3: Blood and Wine

The Witcher 3: Blood and Wine

The Witcher 3: Hearts of Stone

The Witcher 3: Hearts of Stone

See/Add Comments