Brothers in Arms: Earned in Blood

The main pros of the game

• Engaging Storyline: The narrative is compelling, focusing on Sergeant Joe 'Red' Hartsock and providing a deeper emotional connection to the characters and their experiences during WWII.
• Tactical Gameplay: The game emphasizes strategic squad-based mechanics, requiring players to think critically about positioning and tactics, which adds depth to the gameplay.
• Improved AI: Enemy AI is noted to be more challenging and adaptive compared to its predecessor, creating more dynamic encounters.
• Graphics and Atmosphere: The game’s graphics, while dated, are appreciated for their authenticity and detail, effectively conveying the atmosphere of WWII.
• Replayability: Enhanced replayability features, including a skirmish mode and various unlockable content, keep players engaged beyond the main campaign.
• Nostalgic Appeal: Many players express a fondness for the game due to its historical context and gameplay style, often reminiscing about their experiences with it.

The main cons of the game

• Inconsistent AI Performance: While enemy AI is improved, friendly AI is often criticized for being ineffective, leading to frustrating gameplay experiences.
• Gunplay Issues: Many players find the gunplay to be inaccurate and frustrating, with complaints about the weightlessness of shooting and lack of effective feedback when hitting targets.
• Level Design Flaws: Some levels are criticized for poor design choices, such as funneling players into kill zones with limited options for flanking.
• Technical Issues: Players report bugs and performance issues, especially on modern systems, which can detract from the overall experience.
• Difficulty Spike: The game is noted to be significantly harder than its predecessor, which can be off-putting for some players.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Sprinting Mechanic: Players express a desire for a sprinting feature to enhance mobility during combat.
• Better Friendly AI: There is a consensus that improvements in friendly AI are necessary to enhance the squad-based gameplay experience.
• Variety in Soundtrack: Some users feel that the soundtrack lacks variety compared to the previous installment, which detracts from the emotional impact of the game.
• Quick Saving Options: The absence of a quick save feature is noted as a significant drawback, making challenging sections of the game more frustrating.
• More Diverse Gameplay Mechanics: Some players wish for additional gameplay mechanics or features that could enhance tactical options and overall engagement.

Summary

• Overall, *Brothers in Arms: Earned in Blood* is praised for its narrative and tactical depth, but it is also criticized for its AI issues and gunplay mechanics, with players expressing a desire for improvements in these areas.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025