Eschalon: Book I

The main pros of the game

• Classic RPG Experience: Many users appreciate the old-school RPG feel, reminiscent of classic titles, with a focus on exploration and character development.
• Challenging Gameplay: The game offers a significant challenge, especially in the early to mid-game, which is appealing to players looking for a tough experience.
• Rich Worldbuilding: The game features detailed environments, interesting NPCs, and a well-developed lore that enhances immersion.
• Character Customization: Players enjoy the ability to create unique characters with various skills and backgrounds, allowing for diverse gameplay styles.
• Atmospheric Music and Graphics: The music adds to the game's charm, and while the graphics are pixelated, many find them endearing and fitting for the genre.

The main cons of the game

• Slow Movement Speed: Several users find the walking speed frustrating, suggesting that it hampers the overall experience.
• Combat Mechanics: Some reviewers criticize the combat system as being repetitive or lacking depth, particularly in melee encounters.
• Technical Issues: Players have reported problems with the game running on modern systems, particularly regarding resolution and display issues, leading to eye strain.
• Difficulty Curve: There are concerns about the character building system, where poor choices can lead to a challenging progression, making it easy to get stuck.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Improved User Interface: Users have expressed a desire for a more modern interface, including better map features and more intuitive controls.
• Quality of Life Improvements: Suggestions include faster travel options and more streamlined combat mechanics to enhance gameplay.
• Modern Compatibility: Many players wish for updates that would allow the game to run smoothly on contemporary hardware without graphical issues.
• Enhanced Graphics and Animation: There are calls for a graphical update to make the game more visually appealing on modern screens, as the current resolution is considered outdated.

Summary

• Overall, while Eschalon: Book I is praised for its classic RPG elements and challenging gameplay, it faces criticism regarding its technical execution and some gameplay mechanics that could benefit from modernization.

Summary generated on: November 23, 2025