I, Robot

The main pros of the game

• Visuals and Aesthetics: Many users appreciated the psychedelic visuals and colorful graphics that are characteristic of Jeff Minter's style. The option to switch to a starfield background was also noted as a positive feature.
• New Gameplay Elements: The introduction of new enemies, arena levels, and gameplay mechanics added variety and fresh challenges, making the game feel dynamic and engaging.
• Nostalgic Elements: Some players enjoyed the preservation of certain sounds from the original game, such as the "level landing" sound, and felt that the core gameplay loop remained intact.
• Accessibility: Users found the game approachable, allowing for both casual play and more serious high score attempts, catering to a wide range of players.
• Replayability: The game offers multiple goals for each level, enhancing its replay value and encouraging players to explore different strategies.

The main cons of the game

• Deviation from the Original: Many reviews expressed disappointment that the game does not capture the essence of the original "I, Robot," noting that it felt more like a generic Minter game rather than a faithful remake.
• Controls and Gameplay Speed: Users reported issues with unresponsive and "floaty" controls, and many felt the gameplay pace was slower compared to the original, leading to a less engaging experience.
• Visual Overload: The psychedelic visuals, while appreciated by some, were criticized by others for being distracting and making it difficult to discern gameplay elements, especially in fast-paced sections.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Original Game Mechanics: Key features like the "view up/down" mechanic and specific enemies (e.g., sharks, huge beach balls) from the original were missing.
• Bonus Levels: The absence of the pyramid bonus levels and "Big Brother" levels was a significant disappointment for many players, as these added variety and excitement to the original gameplay.
• Clearer Gameplay Indicators: Users suggested that the game could benefit from clearer indicators for gameplay elements, such as making the evil eye larger or providing a tutorial for new mechanics.
• Control Customization: Some players expressed frustration with the lack of control remapping options, particularly on certain platforms like Steam Deck.

Summary

• Overall, while "I, Robot" received praise for its vibrant visuals and innovative gameplay elements, it faced criticism for not fully honoring the original game's spirit and for various gameplay and design shortcomings.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025