Puzzle Quest: Immortal Edition

The main pros of the game

• Nostalgia Factor: Many players appreciate the return of a classic game they loved in the past, often citing fond memories of the original.
• Core Gameplay: The match-3 mechanics combined with RPG elements remain engaging and addictive, providing a satisfying gameplay loop.
• Content Availability: The game includes all DLC and additional content from previous versions, enhancing the overall experience with a wide range of classes, gear, and quests.
• Quality of Life Improvements: Some users noted improvements in graphics and UI, making the game feel more modern and responsive.
• Replayability: The variety of classes and character builds provides significant replay value.

The main cons of the game

• AI Cheating: A significant number of reviews highlight frustrations with the AI, which is perceived to have an unfair advantage through lucky matches and cascading combos that often lead to player losses.
• Visual and Audio Quality: Some players feel that the updated graphics look cheap or generic, and there are complaints about the music being uninspired or AI-generated.
• Reduced Content: Users have expressed disappointment over the removal of features from the original game, such as fewer character portraits and the absence of multiplayer modes.
• Difficulty Issues: Many reviews mention that the game can feel overly difficult due to the AI’s perceived advantages, leading to frustration rather than challenge.
• Bugs and Technical Issues: Some players reported bugs, including corrupted save files and issues with cloud saves, which detracted from their overall experience.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Multiplayer Mode: The absence of a multiplayer option was a common point of disappointment, as previous versions had this feature which added to the longevity of the game.
• Character Customization: Users noted a reduction in character portraits and customization options compared to earlier iterations.
• Balanced Gameplay: There are calls for better balance in gameplay mechanics, particularly regarding the AI difficulty and randomness, which many feel disrupts the strategic aspect of the game.
• Enhanced Storytelling: Some players expressed that the narrative and RPG elements felt generic and lacking compared to what they remembered from the original.

Summary

• In summary, while Puzzle Quest: Immortal Edition has its strengths, particularly in nostalgia and core gameplay, it faces significant criticism regarding AI balance, visual quality, and the removal of features that some players cherished in earlier versions.

Summary generated on: October 16, 2025