Batman: The Telltale Series - The Enemy Within

The main pros of the game

• Engaging Storytelling: The narrative is praised for its depth, complexity, and emotional engagement. Many users highlighted the moral ambiguity and the psychological aspects of the story, making choices feel impactful.
• Character Development: The portrayals of iconic characters, especially the Joker (John Doe), received significant acclaim. Players appreciated the unique take on the Joker's origin and the dynamic between him and Batman.
• Improved Gameplay Mechanics: Several reviews noted enhancements in gameplay, including new quick-time events (QTEs) and combat mechanics that added variety to interactions.
• Visual and Audio Quality: The comic book art style and voice acting were well-received, contributing to the immersive experience of the game.
• Replay Value: The branching narratives and multiple endings encouraged players to replay the game to explore different choices and outcomes.

The main cons of the game

• Overexposure of Batman's Identity: Many users expressed dissatisfaction with the number of characters who knew Bruce Wayne's identity as Batman, feeling it undermined the character's mystique.
• Pacing and Structure Issues: Some reviews mentioned inconsistent pacing, with certain episodes feeling rushed or less engaging than others.
• Gameplay Limitations: While improvements were noted, some players still found the gameplay mechanics to be simplistic or occasionally frustrating, particularly in puzzle-solving aspects.
• Minor Bugs and Technical Issues: A few users reported bugs that affected gameplay, including crashes and issues with subtitles.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• More Detective Work: Some players felt that the game could have included more detective elements, which are a hallmark of the Batman character.
• Rewind Feature: The absence of a chapter rewind option was mentioned as a drawback, making it difficult for players to explore alternative choices without starting over.
• Greater Character Involvement: Users expressed a desire for more substantial roles for certain characters (e.g., Catwoman), indicating that some characters felt underdeveloped in the context of the story.

Summary

• Overall, "Batman: The Enemy Within - The Telltale Series" is considered a strong sequel that builds on its predecessor with improved storytelling, character development, and gameplay mechanics, despite some criticisms regarding pacing and the handling of Batman's identity.

Summary generated on: November 23, 2025