Engaging Gameplay Loop: Players find the combination of dungeon crawling and settlement management enjoyable, with a satisfying cycle of gathering resources, upgrading the settlement, and exploring dungeons.
Tactical Combat: The real-time combat with pause mechanics allows for strategic planning, making battles engaging and challenging.
Unique Blend of Genres: The mix of colony sim and dungeon crawler elements appeals to fans of both genres, offering a fresh experience.
Potential for Growth: Many users express excitement about the game’s potential and the developers’ commitment to updates and improvements in the future.
Charming Art Style: The pixel art and character designs are generally well-received, adding to the game's overall appeal.
The main cons of the game
Shallow Base Building Mechanics: Many players feel that the base-building aspect lacks depth, making it feel more like a chore than a core feature of the game.
Difficulty Spikes: Users report sudden difficulty spikes in combat, especially when progressing to new dungeon levels, which can lead to frustrating experiences.
Limited Character Customization: The inability to create and customize characters fully at the start is a common complaint, as players want more control over their adventurers’ skills and traits.
Resource Management Issues: Players find the management of food and resources cumbersome, especially with limited options for farming and storage.
UI/UX Problems: The user interface is described as clunky, and features like the inability to move built structures without deconstruction are frustrating.
The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users
Expanded Farming System: Players wish for a more robust farming mechanic, including more crop options and the ability to grow food more efficiently.
Character Trait Rerolling: A system to reroll or choose traits for characters would enhance gameplay and reduce reliance on RNG.
Enhanced Combat Mechanics: Suggestions include improving the flow of combat to reduce the need for constant pausing and allowing for more tactical options.
More Dynamic Base Management: Features such as NPC raids or events that would require players to defend their settlement could add depth to the colony sim aspect.
Additional Content: Users are looking for more classes, abilities, and dungeon content to keep the gameplay fresh and engaging.
Summary
Overall, while Dungeon Settlers has a strong foundation and engaging gameplay, it is still in early access and requires further development to address user concerns and enhance the overall experience.