Potionomics

The main pros of the game

• Charming Characters and Story: The characters are well-written, interesting, and have engaging backstories. Users appreciate the depth and personality of each character, enhanced by excellent voice acting.
• Art and Animation: The game features beautiful visuals, charming animations, and a delightful art style that many players find appealing.
• Unique Gameplay Mechanics: The blend of shop management, potion brewing, deck-building (haggling), and dating sim elements creates a unique gameplay experience that many players find enjoyable.
• Variety of Strategies: Players can experiment with different strategies for potion brewing and haggling, allowing for diverse gameplay experiences.
• Quality of Life Updates: Recent updates have added features like an Endless Mode and various difficulty settings, making the game more accessible and enjoyable for different player types.

The main cons of the game

• Time Management Issues: Many players feel the game can become tedious, especially with the time constraints imposed by competitions. The gameplay can feel rushed, leading to stress rather than enjoyment.
• User Interface and Quality of Life: The UI is often criticized for being clunky and not user-friendly, with many players wanting better organization for inventory, recipes, and potion management. Frequent loading screens and cumbersome navigation detract from the overall experience.
• Difficulty Balancing: Some players find the difficulty spikes, especially during competitions, to be frustrating and feel that the game can be unbalanced at times, particularly when it comes to RNG (random number generation) elements affecting potion ingredients.
• Repetitive Gameplay: As the game progresses, some players report that the gameplay becomes repetitive, with less room for experimentation and more focus on grinding for resources and optimizing strategies.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Better Tracking and Organization Tools: Players want features that help track potions, ingredients, and relationships more efficiently, such as saving potion recipes, filtering ingredients, and having a persistent shopping list.
• Enhanced Quality of Life Options: Suggestions include the ability to skip certain animations, quicker navigation between menus, and better sorting options for inventory and recipes.
• Expanded Gameplay Elements: Some players feel that the game could benefit from additional gameplay features, such as mini-games for gathering ingredients or more engaging systems for fulfilling custom orders.
• More Comprehensive Tutorials: Users have expressed a desire for better in-game tutorials or guides to help navigate the various mechanics without needing to rely on external resources.

Summary

• Overall, while Potionomics has many strengths, particularly in character and story design, it also faces criticism regarding its pacing, UI, and some gameplay mechanics that could use improvement.

Summary generated on: November 23, 2025