Rosewater

The main pros of the game

• Engaging Story and Characters: The narrative is captivating, with well-developed characters that players become emotionally invested in. The writing is praised for its depth and humor.
• High Production Quality: Players commend the beautiful art style, rotoscoped animations, and top-notch voice acting, contributing to an immersive experience.
• Replayability: The game features multiple endings and branching paths based on player choices, encouraging replayability to explore different outcomes and character interactions.
• Logical Puzzles: Puzzles are generally well-designed, with multiple solutions that feel organic to the story, avoiding frustrating "moon logic."
• Atmospheric Soundtrack: The music enhances the game's atmosphere and complements the storytelling.

The main cons of the game

• Pacing Issues: Some players feel the beginning is slow and that the middle section, which focuses on traveling and random encounters, can drag on and feel disconnected from the main plot.
• Simplicity of Puzzles: While many enjoyed the puzzles, some found them too easy or lacking challenge, leading to a feeling that the game is more of a visual novel than a traditional adventure game.
• Character Relationships: There are mixed feelings about the relationship system; some players found it unclear and not well-explained in-game, making it difficult to navigate.
• Filler Content: Certain side quests and encounters were viewed as unnecessary or lacking relevance to the main story, which could detract from the overall pacing.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Hint System: Players noted the absence of a hint button or system, which could help during challenging puzzles.
• Fast Travel Options: Some suggested the inclusion of a quick travel feature to reduce time spent moving between locations, which can feel tedious.
• More Detailed Relationship Tracking: A clearer explanation of how player choices affect relationships with companions would enhance player understanding and engagement.
• Additional Gameplay Mechanics: Some users expressed a desire for more varied gameplay elements, such as mini-games or more complex puzzles, to provide additional depth and challenge.

Summary

• Overall, "Rosewater" is well-received for its storytelling and character depth but has room for improvement in pacing and puzzle complexity.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025