Sherlock Holmes: Nemesis

The main pros of the game

• Challenging Puzzles: Many users appreciated the difficulty of the puzzles, which provided a good challenge without holding the player's hand.
• Atmosphere and Setting: The game successfully captures the ambiance of 19th Century London, enhancing the overall experience.
• Improved Controls: Players noted that the controls are better compared to previous installments in the series, making gameplay smoother.
• Engaging Story: The narrative involving Sherlock Holmes and Arséne Lupin is generally well-received, with some players enjoying the playful interactions.
• Hint System: The integrated hint system is praised for helping players when they get stuck, allowing for a more enjoyable experience.
• Multiple Perspectives: The option to switch between different viewpoints is appreciated, especially for those who might experience discomfort with first-person perspectives.

The main cons of the game

• Unclear and Illogical Puzzles: A significant number of reviews mention that many puzzles are either illogical or overly complex, leading to frustration.
• Repetitive Gameplay: Some users felt that certain types of puzzles were repeated too often, lacking variety.
• Technical Issues: Reports of glitches, such as graphical problems and bugs affecting gameplay, detracted from the experience for several players.
• Character Interactions: Some users found the character of Watson to be portrayed negatively, which was off-putting for fans of the original characters.
• Frustrating Navigation: Players expressed frustration with movement and interaction mechanics, which sometimes made it difficult to explore and find clues.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• More Variety in Puzzles: Users suggested that a broader range of puzzle types, particularly incorporating more logic-based challenges instead of math-focused ones, would enhance gameplay.
• Side Quests or Collectibles: Some players noted the absence of side quests or collectible items, which could add depth and replayability to the game.
• Better Clarity in Puzzles: There is a desire for clearer instructions or explanations for puzzles, as some solutions felt arbitrary or poorly explained.
• Improved User Interface: Feedback indicated that the user interface could be more intuitive and less cumbersome, particularly regarding dialogue navigation.

Summary

• Overall, "Sherlock Holmes - Nemesis" has received mixed reviews, with players enjoying the atmosphere and challenging puzzles but expressing frustration over certain gameplay mechanics and puzzle design.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025