Sherlock Holmes vs. Jack the Ripper

The main pros of the game

• Engaging Story: Many reviews praised the game's narrative, highlighting its depth and historical accuracy regarding the Jack the Ripper case. The intertwining leads and complexity of the story were noted as particularly compelling.
• Atmospheric Setting: The game successfully creates a grim and immersive atmosphere reflective of Victorian London, enhancing the overall experience.
• Variety in Puzzles: Users appreciated the variety and challenge of puzzles, with many finding them engaging and rewarding to solve, although some noted that a few were frustratingly difficult.
• Quality of Life Features: The ability to highlight interactable objects (using the space bar) and the option to switch between first and third-person perspectives were well-received.
• Historical Elements: The incorporation of real documents and crime scene details from the era added authenticity to the gameplay.

The main cons of the game

• Technical Issues: Many players reported bugs, including visual glitches and issues with certain puzzles that were either broken or required extensive knowledge (e.g., Civil War puzzles) to solve.
• Voice Acting: The voice acting, particularly for Sherlock Holmes, received significant criticism for being robotic and lacking emotion, which detracted from the immersion.
• Linear Gameplay: Several reviews mentioned the game's linearity, which could lead to feelings of being led by the hand rather than engaging in true detective work.
• Confusing Objectives: Some players found that the game did not adequately communicate objectives, leading to confusion and reliance on walkthroughs.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• More Intuitive Puzzles: Users expressed a desire for puzzles to be clearer or more intuitive, as some were deemed too obscure or required outside knowledge to solve.
• In-Game Hints: The absence of a hint system, which was present in previous games, was noted as a drawback, making it harder for players to progress without external help.
• Improved Navigation: Some players felt that the navigation and inventory management could be streamlined to enhance the gameplay experience.
• Character Development: A few reviews suggested that the characters, particularly Watson, could benefit from deeper development and more engaging interactions.

Summary

• Overall, while "Sherlock Holmes versus Jack the Ripper" has its flaws, particularly related to technical aspects and voice acting, it is still regarded as a worthwhile experience due to its rich story and atmospheric setting.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025