The Black Mirror

The main pros of the game

• Atmosphere and Story: The game is praised for its dark, gothic atmosphere and engaging narrative, which effectively draws players into the mystery surrounding the Gordon family.
• Voice Acting: Many users appreciate the voice acting, especially the German dub, which adds depth to the characters.
• Visuals: While dated, the graphics are considered charming and well-suited to the game's theme.
• Puzzles: Most puzzles are logical and enjoyable, providing a satisfying challenge for players.
• Nostalgia: For many players, the game evokes fond memories, making it a nostalgic experience.

The main cons of the game

• Outdated Mechanics: Players note that the game feels clunky and slow, with sluggish character movement and animation.
• Pixel Hunting: There are frequent instances of pixel hunting, where players must search for tiny interactive items, which can be frustrating.
• Lack of Guidance: The absence of a hint system or clear directions often leaves players wandering aimlessly, especially when they must wait for characters to progress the story.
• Tedious Puzzles: Some puzzles are criticized for being overly complicated or requiring external knowledge, leading to trial and error.

Conclusion

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Hint System: Players express a desire for a hint system to help guide them through puzzles and objectives.
• Faster Movement Options: A feature to speed up character movement or transitions between scenes is noted as a significant missing element, given the game's slow pacing.
• Autosave Functionality: Users highlight the lack of autosave, which can lead to frustration if players die or need to reload an old save.
• More Engaging Dialogue System: Some players wish for an in-game notebook or system to track dialogue and objectives, as the game does not provide reminders of past conversations.
• Improved Animation and Graphics: While the atmosphere is praised, many players feel that the character animations and some graphical elements are outdated and could benefit from improvement.

Summary

• Overall, while Black Mirror I is celebrated for its storytelling and atmospheric qualities, it suffers from mechanics and design choices that reflect its age, leading to a mixed reception among modern players.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025