The Evil Within: The Executioner

The main pros of the game

• Unique First-Person Gameplay: The shift to first-person combat offers a fresh and brutal experience, emphasizing visceral action.
• Strong Story and Character: The narrative provides emotional depth, focusing on the character of The Keeper and his quest to find his daughter.
• Satisfying Gore and Atmosphere: The game features intense combat paired with a trademark atmosphere of dread, making the gore feel impactful.
• Replayability: Players noted the potential for replaying the game and enjoying the action-packed sequences multiple times.
• Fun Combat Mechanics: The gameplay is described as entertaining and enjoyable, with a focus on smashing enemies.

The main cons of the game

• Repetitive Encounters: Some players found the gameplay to become monotonous due to similar combat scenarios.
• Slow Character Movement: The deliberate speed of The Keeper can make gameplay feel sluggish, particularly during backtracking or chase sequences.
• Short Length: The DLC is relatively brief, lasting about 1-1.5 hours, which some players felt was too short for a satisfying experience.
• Janky Controls: Issues with the controls, especially for mouse and keyboard users, detracted from the overall experience, with recommendations to use a controller instead.
• Lower Production Quality: Some reviews indicated that the DLC felt less polished compared to the main game, suggesting it lacked the same level of investment and effort.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Lack of Horror Elements: Many players noted that the DLC focuses more on action than horror, lacking the tension and suspense that characterized the base game.
• Variety in Environments: The environments were criticized for being repetitive, as they primarily take place in the same location (Victoriano Estate) throughout the DLC.
• Depth in Gameplay Mechanics: Some players felt that the combat mechanics were tedious and could have benefited from more variety or complexity.
• Voice Acting and Cutscenes: The absence of animated cutscenes and voice acting was pointed out as a significant downgrade compared to the main game, leading to a less immersive experience.

Summary

• Overall, "The Evil Within: The Executioner" is seen as an entertaining, albeit short and somewhat flawed, addition to the series, with a focus on action and gore rather than horror.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025