Victory at Sea: Atlantic

The main pros of the game

• Potential for Depth: Many users recognize the game’s potential to become a leading WWII naval sim, especially with further updates and improvements.
• Engaging Naval Battles: Players appreciate the excitement of ship battles and the control over units, finding the combat loud and brutal.
• Visuals and Graphics: The graphics, particularly the depiction of weather and sea conditions, are praised for their quality and immersion.
• Variety of Ships: The game offers a wide array of ships, planes, and submarines, allowing for diverse gameplay experiences.
• Active Development: Developers are noted for being responsive to player feedback and actively working on improvements and bug fixes.
• Complexity and Strategy: The game includes elements of resource management and tactical planning, which some players find rewarding.

The main cons of the game

• Basic Combat Mechanics: Players criticize the combat for its lack of depth and realism, feeling it leans too much towards an arcade style rather than a strategic simulation.
• Unbalanced AI: Many reviews mention issues with AI difficulty, where it feels skewed in favor of the AI, leading to frustrating gameplay experiences.
• Bugs and Technical Issues: Numerous players report encountering bugs in combat, menus, and tutorials, which detracts from the overall experience.
• Pricing Concerns: Some users express dissatisfaction with the game’s pricing model, feeling it is too high for a product that still feels incomplete.
• Repetitive Gameplay: A number of reviews mention boredom due to repetitive gameplay and lack of engaging content over time.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Realism in Naval Tactics: Players desire a more strategic representation of naval warfare, particularly for U-boats, which should emphasize stealth and ambush tactics.
• Improved AI: Many users call for better AI behavior to enhance the challenge and engagement during gameplay.
• Enhanced Damage Models: There are requests for more realistic ship damage and sinking animations, which would increase immersion.
• More Starting Points: Some players feel the game should offer varied starting points to provide a more balanced and engaging experience from the beginning.
• Detailed Tutorials: While some tutorials are appreciated, others find them overwhelming or lacking in clarity, suggesting a need for more user-friendly guidance, especially for newcomers.
• Additional Content: Users express a desire for more ships, improved animations, and overall content updates to enrich gameplay.

Summary

• Overall, while "Victory at Sea Atlantic" shows promise and has some strong features, significant improvements are needed to meet player expectations and enhance the overall experience.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025