Ys: The Oath in Felghana

The main pros of the game

• Engaging Combat: Players consistently praise the fast-paced and responsive combat mechanics, noting that it feels satisfying and rewarding. The boss fights are highlighted as particularly memorable and challenging, requiring skill and strategy.
• Exceptional Soundtrack: The game's music, composed by Falcom Sound Team jdk, is frequently described as outstanding, enhancing the overall experience with its mix of rock and orchestral elements.
• Challenging Gameplay: Many users appreciate the game's difficulty, which they find rewarding. The need for precision and pattern recognition in combat is seen as a positive element that adds depth to the gameplay.
• Well-Designed Levels: The level design is noted for its variety, combining puzzles, platforming, and combat, keeping the gameplay fresh and engaging throughout.
• Short and Focused Experience: The game is praised for its concise length, generally around 10-15 hours, which prevents it from overstaying its welcome.

The main cons of the game

• Frustrating Difficulty Spikes: While many enjoy the challenge, some players find certain bosses and sections excessively difficult, leading to frustration. This is especially noted in the context of the game's lack of on-demand healing.
• Limited Exploration and Side Quests: Users express disappointment over the sparse side quests and the relatively linear world design, which lacks the depth and exploration found in other RPGs.
• Dated Graphics: Although some appreciate the retro aesthetic, others feel that the graphics have not aged well and may not appeal to modern gamers.
• Voice Acting Issues: The English voice acting is described as a mixed bag, with some characters receiving praise while others are criticized, leading to a desire for Japanese voice acting options.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• More Robust Storytelling: Some players feel that the narrative is too simplistic and could benefit from deeper character development and lore, especially given the rich history of the Ys series.
• Quality of Life Improvements: Users mention a desire for features such as quick saves or more frequent save points, as well as options for more varied difficulty settings that could accommodate different player skill levels.
• Expanded Exploration: Several reviews indicate that the game could have benefited from a larger world to explore and more side quests, which would enhance the overall experience and replayability.

Summary

• Overall, Ys: The Oath in Felghana is viewed as a solid action RPG with engaging mechanics and a fantastic soundtrack, but it also faces criticism for its difficulty and narrative simplicity.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025