Sherlock Holmes The Devil's Daughter: A Study in Green - Deductions

Final deduction

This is how a correctly constructed hypothesis looks like

Albeit is guilty

Required assumptions:

• Fear;
• Small stature;
• Attacks;
• Suspect is small;
• No automaton;
• False statement;
• Prepared;
• Unaware;
• Bitterness;
• no curse;
• Other collections;
• Testimonies;
• Albeit's lies;
• Temple model

This hypothesis assumes that Albeit is guilty. You can select whether you like to condemn him or let him live freely. During the conversation with him lose the hat from the head of the small person to reveal the truth about his accomplice.

Incorrect deductions

The Curse is real

Required assumptions:

• Fear;
• Small stature;
• Attacks;
• Son is innocent;
• No automaton;
• Running statue;
• Prepared;
• Unaware;
• No revenge;
• Curse is real;
• Other collections;
• Testimonies;
• Albeit's lies;
• Temple model;

In this option Holmes assumes that the curse is real and he ends the investigation. You can keep that information to yourself or blame inspector Lestrade for incompetence.

Bernard Marley is guilty

You need following evidence:

• The chosen one;
• Small stature;
• Attacks;
• Son is innocent;
• Automaton;
• Running statue;
• Witness;
• Prepared;
• Unaware;
• No revenge;
• No Curse;
• Other collections;
• Testimonies;
• Albeit's lies;
• Temple model;

According to this assumption Bernard Marley is guilty and he wanted to become the chosen one. You can send him to jail for his mortal actions or you can send him to mental care facility.

Sir Charles is guilty

Required evidence:

• Fear;
• Small stature;
• Attacks;
• Son is innocent;
• No automaton;
• False statement;
• Strength;
• Prepared;
• Opportunity;
• No revenge;
• No curse;
• Club debts;
• Testimonies;
• Albeit's lies;
• Temple model;

In this theory you assume that Sir Charles is to blame for the murder. You can send him to jail or you can acquit him.

Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter

June 10, 2016

Rate It!

• Overview
• Guide