Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter

The main pros of the game

• Variety of Puzzles: Many players appreciated the diverse range of puzzles that challenge players' deductive skills.
• Deduction Interface: The interface for connecting clues and making deductions was praised for its uniqueness and engagement.
• Immersive Detective Experience: Players enjoyed the feeling of being a detective, searching for clues, and making impactful decisions that affect the story.
• Visuals and Atmosphere: Some reviews noted that the game captures the ambiance of post-Victorian London effectively, contributing to the overall experience.
• Casual Gameplay: The game is seen as suitable for relaxed gaming sessions filled with riddles and mysteries.

The main cons of the game

• Short Story Length: Several users felt that the overall story was too brief, leaving them wanting more content.
• Annoying Mini-Games: Specific mini-games, such as lockpicking and quick-time events, were criticized for being frustrating and excessive.
• Technical Issues: There were reports of bugs, crashes, and lag, particularly on certain hardware setups, which negatively impacted gameplay.
• Poor Pacing and Structure: Many players found the pacing uneven, with some chapters feeling too short and others overly long and tedious.
• Lack of Clear Guidance: Users pointed out that the game often fails to guide players adequately on what actions to take after gathering clues.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• More Engaging Storylines: Players expressed a desire for deeper, more complex narratives and character development, especially compared to previous titles in the series.
• Improved Control and Navigation: Many reviews highlighted the need for better controls and a more intuitive interface for navigating clues and making deductions.
• Manual Save Options: Users were frustrated by the inability to save manually or have multiple save slots, which limited their control over gameplay.
• Less Linear Gameplay: Some players wished for a more open-world experience rather than a linear progression, allowing for more exploration and interaction with the environment.
• Logical Consistency in Clues: There were complaints about certain clues and sequences lacking logical coherence, making it difficult for players to deduce correctly.

Summary

• Overall, while "Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter" has its strengths in puzzle variety and atmosphere, it faces significant criticism regarding its story depth, technical execution, and gameplay mechanics.

Summary generated on: October 24, 2025