Arcania: Fall of Setarrif

The main pros of the game

• Graphics: Some areas are visually polished, providing a slightly pleasant aesthetic experience.
• Character Importing: Players can import their character from the base game with all levels and equipment, allowing for a smoother start.
• Additional Content: The game offers a few extra quests and locations, which some users found enjoyable despite being uninspired.

The main cons of the game

• Unfixable Core Issues: The base game was already flawed, and the expansion does not address these problems.
• Short Length: Many users noted that the game is very short, with completion times ranging from 3 to 8 hours.
• Bland Story and Characters: The narrative is considered forgettable and lacks depth, failing to engage players.
• Shallow Gameplay and Combat: Combat remains clunky and uninspired, with users expressing disappointment in the lack of meaningful gameplay mechanics.
• Linear Experience: The game lacks meaningful choices and feels linear, with no significant impact on the game world.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Lack of Depth: Fans of the Gothic series missed the immersive world and meaningful choices that characterized earlier games in the series.
• Engaging Storytelling: The absence of a compelling narrative and character development was a significant drawback.
• Replay Value: Players felt there was little incentive to replay the game after completing it once.
• Dynamic World: Users commented on the lifelessness of the game world, where cities and wilderness areas felt empty and devoid of danger or adventure.
• Improved Mechanics: There was a desire for more complex gameplay mechanics and crafting systems that were present in earlier Gothic titles but were simplified or missing in this expansion.

Summary

• Overall, "ArcaniA: Fall of Setarrif" seems to have disappointed many fans of the Gothic series, offering a visually polished but shallow experience that fails to capture the depth and engagement of its predecessors.

Summary generated on: October 28, 2025