Black Mirror

The main pros of the game

• Atmosphere and Setting: The game effectively creates a dark and eerie atmosphere, with a spooky Scottish castle setting that many players found immersive.
• Story and Characters: The narrative is engaging with suspenseful elements, and some players appreciated the character development and plot twists, reminiscent of classic mystery tales.
• Puzzles: While some felt there were too few, others found the puzzles to be interesting and balanced.
• Voice Acting: The voice acting, particularly in the German version, received positive remarks for its quality.
• Exploration: Players enjoyed the exploration aspect of the game, with many noting the intrigue of investigating a haunted manor.

The main cons of the game

• Controls and Mechanics: A significant number of players criticized the clunky controls, awkward camera angles, and issues with character movement, which often led to frustration during gameplay.
• Technical Issues: Numerous bugs, including freezing and soft-locking, were reported, detracting from the overall experience.
• Length and Depth: Many reviewers found the game to be too short (around 6-8 hours) and lacking in the depth and complexity that fans expected from a Black Mirror title.
• Visual Quality: Graphics were deemed average, with complaints about poor lighting, clipping issues, and general visual polish.
• Lack of Challenging Puzzles: Some players felt that the puzzles were too simplistic and did not provide the level of challenge expected from adventure games.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Point-and-Click Mechanics: Longtime fans of the original trilogy missed the classic point-and-click gameplay style, as the game shifted to a more free-roaming approach.
• Complex Puzzles: Many users noted a lack of meaningful and challenging puzzles, feeling that the game did not capture the essence of the original series.
• Character Depth: Players expressed disappointment in the character development, stating that the characters lacked the charm and depth present in the earlier games.
• Consistent Audio Quality: Issues with audio, such as inconsistent voice quality and translation errors, were mentioned as detracting from the overall experience.
• Narrative Cohesion: Some players felt that the story was underdeveloped, with unresolved questions and a rushed ending that did not satisfy their expectations.

Summary

• Overall, while Black Mirror (2017) has its merits, particularly in atmosphere and story potential, it falls short in gameplay mechanics and technical execution, leading to a mixed reception from users.

Summary generated on: November 17, 2025