Costume Quest 2

The main pros of the game

• Charming Presentation: The game's art style is praised for its colorful, whimsical visuals that evoke the spirit of Halloween.
• Nostalgic and Fun: Many players appreciate the nostalgic feel and light-hearted tone, making it a cozy experience reminiscent of childhood.
• Accessible Gameplay: The turn-based combat is straightforward, making it easy for players of all ages to engage with the game.
• Short Playtime: The game can be completed relatively quickly, making it ideal for casual play, especially during the Halloween season.
• Humorous Writing: The dialogue and humor are well-received, contributing to an enjoyable narrative experience.
• Replay Value: Many players find the game engaging enough to replay, with collectibles and achievements adding to the fun.

The main cons of the game

• Repetitive Combat: Several reviews mention that the combat can become dull and repetitive, especially with the removal of features like battle stamps from the first game.
• Simplistic Challenges: The game is considered easy, lacking complexity and depth in combat and overall gameplay, which may not satisfy players looking for more challenging experiences.
• Short Length: While some appreciate the brevity, others feel that the game could use more content or depth, leaving some players wanting more.
• Technical Issues on Steam Deck: Users reported bugs and control issues when playing on Steam Deck, detracting from the overall experience.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Battle Stamps: Players miss the battle stamps from the first game, which added variety and strategy to combat.
• Complex Combat Mechanics: Many feel that the combat lacks the engaging complexity of the first game, with the new card system feeling like an afterthought.
• Expanded Content: Some users express a desire for more quests, a deeper story, or additional gameplay features to enhance replayability and engagement.
• Improved Controls: Players noted issues with controller compatibility and functionality, particularly on the Steam Deck, indicating a need for better control schemes.

Summary

• Overall, while Costume Quest 2 is celebrated for its charm and nostalgia, it faces criticism for its repetitive combat, ease of play, and technical issues, particularly on certain platforms.

Summary generated on: November 21, 2025