Cyclopean: The Great Abyss

The main pros of the game

• Atmosphere and Aesthetic: Many users praised the game's retro, monochromatic graphics and immersive sound design, which effectively capture Lovecraftian themes and create a haunting atmosphere. The visuals evoke nostalgia for classic RPGs, enhancing the overall experience.
• Gameplay Mechanics: Players enjoyed the mechanics of exploration, combat, and ally recruitment. The ability to interact with NPCs and make strategic decisions regarding allies and combat approaches was highlighted as a significant positive aspect.
• Replayability: The presence of multiple endings, strategic options, and a roguelike mode encourages players to revisit the game. Users appreciated the depth of gameplay and the challenge it presents.
• Developer Engagement: The developer's responsiveness to feedback and active involvement in addressing bugs and issues received positive mentions, contributing to a sense of community among players.

The main cons of the game

• Combat System: Several reviews criticized the combat mechanics as overly simplistic, likening it to a "glorified dice roll" with little player agency. The lack of depth in combat options and the reliance on RNG were points of contention.
• Difficulty and Design Choices: Some players found the game frustrating due to unexpected challenges, such as spawning in difficult situations or encountering bugs that hindered progress. The lack of clear guidance on game mechanics and the necessity for frequent saving were also criticized.
• Technical Issues: Users reported crashes and bugs, particularly when exiting dungeons, which detracted from the overall experience. These issues are expected in early access but still impacted player enjoyment.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Quality of Life Improvements: Suggestions included the need for easier inventory management, auto-mapping features, and more intuitive controls for using items like torches. Players expressed a desire for a journal or note-taking feature to track quests and lore.
• Expanded Lore and Quests: Some users noted the absence of traditional quests and suggested that more structured questing elements or lore exploration could enhance the narrative experience.
• Combat Depth: Many players called for more complex combat mechanics, including skills, abilities, and modifiers that would allow for greater player agency and strategy during battles.

Summary

• Overall, Cyclopean: The Great Abyss has garnered a mix of praise and criticism, with its unique atmosphere and engaging mechanics standing out, while technical issues and simplistic combat mechanics have drawn concern from players.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025