Edge Islands

The main pros of the game

• Unique Blend of Genres: The combination of colony simulation and tactical RPG elements is well-received, offering a fresh take on both genres.
• Engaging Gameplay: Players find the game both relaxing and engaging, with a good balance between building and combat.
• Potential for Growth: Many users express optimism about the game's future development, noting its strong foundation and the developer's responsiveness to feedback.
• Replayability: Features like procedurally generated maps and dungeons add significant replay value.
• Turn-Based Combat: The turn-based combat system is appreciated, allowing for strategic planning rather than chaotic real-time combat.

The main cons of the game

• Steep Learning Curve: New players may find the game challenging to start due to a lack of guidance and a complex interface.
• Gameplay Issues: Users report problems with character prioritization, pathfinding, and resource management, leading to inefficiencies in gameplay.
• Limited Content: Many reviews mention that the game feels unfinished or lacking in content, with players desiring more building options, crafting systems, and enemy variety.
• Bugs and Technical Issues: Some users experience bugs, crashes, and issues with the user interface, which detracts from the overall experience.
• Resource Management Problems: Issues with inventory management and the need for better stockpile controls are frequently mentioned.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Improved Resource Management: Users want the ability to manage resources more effectively, such as by designating specific storage areas for different items.
• Crafting and Equipment Variety: There is a demand for crafting systems that allow players to create weapons, armor, and a wider variety of food options.
• Expanded Character Development: Players desire more character classes, skills, and traits to enhance gameplay depth.
• Dynamic Environment and Events: Suggestions include adding more diverse exploration opportunities, enemy types, and environmental interactions to enrich gameplay.
• Quality of Life Improvements: Many players request enhancements to the user interface and controls to streamline gameplay and improve the overall experience.

Summary

• Overall, while Edge Islands shows great potential and has a dedicated player base, it requires further development and refinement to address existing issues and expand its content.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025