Eldritch

The main pros of the game

• Atmospheric Design: Many users appreciate the game's unique art style and atmospheric sound design, which contribute to its eerie and immersive experience.
• Exploration and Gameplay Variety: Players enjoy the freedom to approach challenges in multiple ways, utilizing stealth, combat, and environmental manipulation. The procedural generation of dungeons keeps exploration fresh and rewarding.
• Accessibility: Several reviews highlight that Eldritch is an approachable roguelike, making it suitable for both newcomers and seasoned players. The gameplay is described as fun, frantic, and engaging, with a satisfying loop once players grasp the mechanics.
• Replayability: Despite some concerns about content, many users find the game engaging enough to warrant multiple playthroughs, especially with the New Game+ feature and the free "Mountains of Madness" expansion.
• Charming and Fun: The game has a certain charm and is described as addicting, with players enjoying the low-pressure environment and the balance of challenge.

The main cons of the game

• Limited Content: Some users feel that after several runs, the game lacks enough variety in items, enemies, and environments, leading to diminished replayability.
• Gameplay Depth: While the game offers various approaches, some reviews note that the immersive sim elements are not deeply developed, and certain strategies can dominate gameplay, reducing the incentive to experiment.
• Difficulty Balance: A few players mentioned that the game isn't particularly challenging, which might not appeal to those seeking a tougher experience. There are also mentions of frustrating moments, such as being walled off from exits.
• Not for Everyone: A couple of reviews indicate that the game may not appeal to all players, particularly those who do not enjoy roguelikes or the specific gameplay style of Eldritch.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• More Weapons and Gear Options: Users expressed a desire for a broader variety of weapons, gear, and power-ups to enhance gameplay and strategic choices.
• Deeper Immersive Sim Elements: Some players wished for a more in-depth implementation of immersive sim mechanics, as they felt the current offerings were somewhat superficial.
• Increased Content: There is a general consensus that more content, such as additional dungeons, items, and enemies, could significantly improve replayability and overall enjoyment.
• Community Engagement: A few reviews suggested that an active modding community or regular updates could help maintain interest in the game over time.

Summary

• Overall, Eldritch is seen as a charming and atmospheric indie title that successfully blends roguelike mechanics with immersive sim elements, though it may leave some players wanting more in terms of content and depth.

Summary generated on: November 23, 2025