Elroy and the Aliens

The main pros of the game

• Art and Graphics: The game features vibrant, hand-drawn graphics that many users found appealing and reminiscent of classic adventure games from the 90s. The animations and character designs received positive feedback for their charm and expressiveness.
• Voice Acting and Soundtrack: The voice acting is described as top-notch, with engaging performances that enhance the overall storytelling experience. The soundtrack complements the game's atmosphere well.
• Humor and Story: The narrative is considered engaging, humorous, and heartfelt, with a nostalgic feel that resonates with fans of classic point-and-click adventures. Many users enjoyed the character interactions and witty dialogue.
• Accessibility: The game is praised for being beginner-friendly, making it a good entry point for new players to the genre. The puzzles are generally straightforward, allowing for a smooth gameplay experience.
• Multiple Endings: The presence of different endings based on player choices adds replayability and depth to the story.

The main cons of the game

• Puzzle Difficulty: Many users noted that the puzzles were too easy, lacking the challenge typically expected from point-and-click games. Some felt that the game held players' hands too much, reducing the satisfaction of solving puzzles.
• Cliché Elements: Some characters, especially the villain, were criticized for having predictable and cliché backstories, which detracted from the overall narrative impact.
• Dialogue Length: A few players found the dialogue to be overly long or tedious, leading to moments where they felt compelled to click through conversations rather than engage with them fully.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Journal or Reminder System: Users expressed a desire for a journal feature to help track quests and objectives, as they sometimes felt lost, especially in the latter parts of the game.
• More Complex Puzzles: There were requests for puzzles that could provide a greater challenge, particularly for seasoned players of the genre who found the existing puzzles trivial.
• Skip Options for Cutscenes: Some players wanted the ability to skip cutscenes, especially when replaying sections to unlock different endings, as they felt this would enhance the overall experience.
• Localization Options: A few reviews mentioned the absence of additional language options, such as a German voiceover, which could broaden the game's appeal.

Summary

• Overall, "Elroy and the Aliens" is viewed positively, particularly for its nostalgic charm, engaging storytelling, and accessibility for new players, while also facing criticism for its simplicity and lack of depth in puzzle design.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025