Harold Halibut

The main pros of the game

• Artistic Design: The game features a stunning handmade claymation art style that many players found captivating and unique.
• Atmosphere and Soundtrack: The atmosphere is described as vibrant and immersive, with a beautiful soundtrack that enhances the emotional experience.
• Story and Characters: The narrative explores deep themes of friendship, belonging, and the human condition, resonating with many players. The characters are well-written and evoke empathy.
• Emotional Impact: Several players noted that the story could evoke strong emotions, with moments of humor, sadness, and introspection.
• Voice Acting: The voice acting is generally praised for its quality and contributes to the overall charm of the game.

The main cons of the game

• Pacing and Gameplay: The game is criticized for its slow pacing, with many players feeling that it drags on due to excessive walking and fetch quests. Some described it as more of an interactive movie than a game.
• Lack of Player Agency: Many reviewers noted the absence of meaningful choices and gameplay mechanics, leading to a feeling of being on a predetermined path without real engagement.
• Repetitiveness: The gameplay often involves repetitive tasks and backtracking, which some players found tedious and boring.
• Dialogue Quality: While some appreciated the writing, others found it to be overly long, occasionally dull, and lacking depth.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• More Interactive Gameplay: Players expressed a desire for more engaging gameplay mechanics, such as puzzles or choices that would affect the story.
• Reduced Fetch Quests: Many reviews suggested that the number of fetch quests should be minimized or made more meaningful to enhance the experience.
• Improved Pacing: Several users felt that the game could be shorter or more tightly edited to maintain engagement throughout.
• Localization Options: Some players noted the lack of a German voiceover, which could have made the game more accessible to a wider audience.

Summary

• Overall, Harold Halibut is appreciated for its artistic vision and emotional storytelling but criticized for its pacing and gameplay mechanics. It appeals to those who enjoy narrative-driven experiences and are willing to embrace a slower pace.

Summary generated on: October 30, 2025