Sherlock Holmes: The Mystery of the Persian Carpet

The main pros of the game

• Puzzles Variety: Many users appreciated the variety of puzzles, noting that each puzzle type is different and not repetitive.
• Nostalgic Graphics: Some players found the old-style graphics charming and reminiscent of games from the late 90s and early 2000s.
• Relaxed Gameplay: Several reviews highlighted the game as a chill experience, especially when played in a casual mode without a timer.
• Engaging Story Elements: The narrative was noted to capture the essence of Sherlock Holmes, with some players enjoying the unfolding mystery and the character interactions.
• Playability: Despite its flaws, many players found the game to be playable and enjoyable in short sessions, especially when included in a bundle.

The main cons of the game

• Hidden Object Mechanics: A significant number of reviews criticized the game for being overly reliant on hidden object mechanics, with many objects being hard to find due to poor visibility or blending into backgrounds.
• Poor Instructions: Players noted that the game often provided unclear instructions for puzzles, leading to confusion and frustration.
• Repetitive and Tedious: Some reviews mentioned that the gameplay felt repetitive and lacking excitement, with certain puzzles being tedious or time-consuming.
• Weak Narrative Connection: Many users felt that the game did not do a good job of connecting clues or advancing the story, making the narrative feel minimal and disjointed.
• Technical Issues: Some players experienced bugs or found the game to be poorly optimized for modern systems.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Voice Acting: Many users expressed disappointment over the absence of voice acting, which could have enhanced the narrative experience.
• Clearer Instructions: A demand for clearer instructions on puzzles and gameplay mechanics was a common theme, as players often struggled to understand what was required.
• Dynamic Gameplay Elements: Some reviewers indicated that the game lacked more engaging or dynamic gameplay features, such as meaningful deduction or investigation mechanics typical of traditional adventure games.
• Achievements: Players noted the absence of achievements, which could have added an additional layer of motivation to complete the game.
• Enhanced Visuals: Given that the game was released in 2008, some players expected better graphics and visual fidelity, especially in a hidden object game where clarity is crucial.

Summary

• Overall, while "Sherlock Holmes: The Mystery of the Persian Carpet" has its charms and can be enjoyable for fans of hidden object games, it is marred by several flaws that may deter players seeking a more polished and engaging experience.

Summary generated on: November 20, 2025