Age of Wonders 4: Secrets of the Archmages

The main pros of the game

• New Content: The DLC introduces 6 new tomes, which are well-received for their creativity and gameplay mechanics, adding depth and variety to strategies.
• Visual and Artistic Quality: Players appreciate the fantastic unit designs and spell effects, highlighting the artistic work of the developers.
• Unique Gameplay Mechanics: The introduction of pocket dimensions (Shrouded Isles) and secret spells adds new layers to gameplay, allowing for strategic exploration and resource management.
• Story Realms: The story realms offer interesting narratives and gameplay twists, with some realms being praised for their ambition and unique objectives.
• Quality of Life Improvements: There are mentions of significant improvements in gameplay mechanics and unit interactions, making the game feel richer and more enjoyable.

The main cons of the game

• AI Issues: Players report that the AI has an unfair advantage, particularly regarding the claiming of portals, leading to frustrating gameplay experiences where the AI rushes resources before players have a chance to engage.
• Bugs and Stability: Many reviews mention that the DLC is bug-ridden, with game crashes and other technical issues that hinder the overall experience.
• Balancing Problems: Some story realms are noted to be either too difficult or poorly balanced, particularly in the early game, making them less enjoyable for players.
• Perceived Lack of Value: There are complaints about the price point of the DLC, with many feeling that the amount of content does not justify the $20 cost, especially compared to previous expansions.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• New Cultures or Ruler Types: Players express disappointment over the absence of new cultures or ruler types, which many feel would enhance replayability and variety.
• More Thematic Consistency: Some users feel that the new tomes lack a cohesive theme and instead seem like disparate additions that could have been better integrated or expanded upon.
• Improved AI Behavior: There is a call for better AI management, especially regarding allies and their ability to defend territories or engage effectively in battles.
• Expanded Content: Players desire more substantial content in terms of story missions or gameplay mechanics to make the DLC feel more complete and engaging.

Summary

• Overall, while Secrets of the Archmages has its strengths in new content and artistic quality, it also faces significant criticism regarding balance, technical issues, and perceived value, leading to mixed reviews from the player base.

Summary generated on: July 13, 2026