All Quiet in the Trenches

The main pros of the game

• Compelling Storytelling: Many users praised the game's narrative, highlighting its immersive storytelling that captures the emotional depth and historical details of World War I.
• Character Development: Players appreciated the unique and endearing characters, forming attachments to their squad members and feeling the weight of their decisions.
• Atmosphere and Art Style: The game's visual style and atmosphere were noted as strong points, contributing to the overall experience of trench warfare.
• Engaging Resource Management: The management aspect of keeping soldiers alive and balancing their needs against military objectives was seen as a unique gameplay element that added depth.
• Replayability: Players found the game to have high replay value due to different narrative paths and character interactions.

The main cons of the game

• Combat Mechanics: Many users criticized the combat system as janky, with issues like soldiers failing to engage properly or animations lacking fluidity. The combat often felt unsatisfying and disconnected from player actions.
• Repetitive Gameplay: Some players noted that the management tasks and battles became monotonous, lacking sufficient variety or dynamic events to keep the gameplay engaging over time.
• AI Issues: Users reported frustrations with the AI, both in combat and during camp management, where soldiers would behave unpredictably or fail to follow orders effectively.
• Lack of Player Agency: The game's design often forced players into scripted scenarios, limiting their ability to make meaningful decisions that impact the outcome of battles or the overall narrative.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Dynamic Events: Players suggested adding more varied events, both serious and lighthearted, to break up the monotony of gameplay and enhance immersion.
• Customizable Gameplay: Users expressed a desire for a sandbox mode or greater customization options for characters, battles, and objectives.
• Improved Combat System: Many reviews called for enhancements to combat mechanics, including better control over soldier actions, clearer objectives, and more engaging animations.
• Training and Skill Development: Players wanted a system for training soldiers to improve their skills or remove negative traits, adding depth to character progression.
• Clearer Feedback Mechanisms: Users requested more visible indicators for resource management, soldier morale, and the impact of decisions, to better understand the consequences of their actions.

Summary

• Overall, while "All Quiet in the Trenches" has a strong foundation and potential for development, it faces challenges in combat mechanics, gameplay variety, and user agency that players hope will be addressed in future updates.

Summary generated on: October 30, 2025