Blackguards: Definitive Edition

The main pros of the game

• Engaging Story and Characters: Many players appreciated the well-written and voiced characters, as well as the morally grey narrative that deviates from typical hero tropes.
• Unique Art Direction: The game features varied and beautiful artistic backdrops, with distinct NPC portraits that enhance the visual experience despite the overall graphics being considered middling.
• Tactical Combat Mechanics: The hex-based combat system offers depth and variety, with hand-crafted battlegrounds that include interactive elements, environmental hazards, and unique battle objectives.
• Rich Side Quests: Players found the side quests to be compelling, providing meaningful content and opportunities for character development and unique gear.
• Varied Battle Arenas: Each combat scenario is designed differently, which keeps the gameplay fresh and engaging.

The main cons of the game

• Bugs and Technical Issues: Many users reported crashes, bugs, and broken achievements that detracted from the overall experience.
• RNG Dependence: The game is heavily reliant on random number generation for combat outcomes, leading to frustrating experiences where players miss high-percentage attacks or face overwhelming odds.
• Underwhelming Gear and Skills: Players noted that while there are various weapon types, the visual appeal and effectiveness of gear and skills often felt lackluster and uninspired.
• Minimal Overworld Navigation: The overworld map and quest system were described as confusing and lacking direction, making it difficult for players to track progress and discover side quests.
• Clunky User Experience: Several reviews mentioned a lack of polish in the game’s mechanics and navigation, contributing to a frustrating experience.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Better Direction and Guidance: Many players felt that the game could benefit from clearer instructions and guidance, particularly regarding side quests and navigation.
• Character Respec Options: Players expressed a desire for the ability to reset or reallocate skill points, as some builds felt ineffective or unbalanced.
• Improved Spell Mechanics: Users noted that spellcasting could be frustrating due to low success rates and the lack of effective offensive spells, leading to a feeling of unreliability in magic use.
• Enhanced Visuals and UI: Several reviews suggested that the game could use a graphical overhaul and improved user interface for a more modern gaming experience.
• More Engaging Combat Mechanics: Some players desired a more strategic approach to combat that minimized the reliance on RNG and provided clearer tactical options.

Summary

• In summary, while Blackguards has a strong narrative and engaging tactical elements, it suffers from technical issues and gameplay mechanics that can frustrate players. The game may appeal to fans of character-driven stories and tactical RPGs, especially if they are willing to overlook its shortcomings.

Summary generated on: October 28, 2025