Dear Esther

The main pros of the game

• Artistic Value: Many users praise Dear Esther for its artistic qualities, describing it as a "masterpiece" and a significant work of art that explores themes of isolation and guilt. The emotional depth and haunting narrative are highlighted as strong points.
• Visuals and Atmosphere: The game features beautiful scenery and atmospheric environments, which contribute to its immersive experience. Users appreciate the graphical quality, especially for its time, and find the island's mood comforting.
• Sound Design: The music and voice acting are also well-received, with many noting that the soundtrack enhances the overall experience and emotional impact of the story.
• Pioneering the Genre: As one of the first walking simulators, it is recognized for paving the way for future titles in the genre, setting a precedent for narrative-driven exploration games.

The main cons of the game

• Gameplay Limitations: Users frequently mention the lack of traditional gameplay elements, such as puzzles or challenges, leading to a perception that it is more of an "experience" than a game. The slow pacing and minimal interaction can result in boredom for some players.
• Narrative Issues: While the story is appreciated for its depth, some users find it confusing or opaque, with disjointed clues and an unreliable narrator that makes it difficult to grasp the full narrative.
• Short Length: The game can be completed in a very short time (around 2-3 hours), which some players feel does not justify the price, leading to dissatisfaction regarding its value.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Interactivity: Many users express a desire for more interactive components, as the game is criticized for being too passive. Players looking for engaging gameplay mechanics may find it lacking.
• Clearer Narrative: Some reviews indicate a wish for a more coherent and accessible storyline, as the current narrative structure may leave players feeling lost or frustrated.
• Challenges or Puzzles: Users mention that the game could benefit from additional gameplay elements, such as puzzles or challenges, to enhance engagement and provide a more fulfilling experience.

Summary

• Overall, while Dear Esther is celebrated for its artistic merits and emotional storytelling, it is also critiqued for its gameplay limitations and narrative complexities.

Summary generated on: November 21, 2025