Rise of Piracy

The main pros of the game

• Unique Features: The game offers innovative mechanics such as adjustable cannon angles, customizable loadouts, and RTS-style controls, which are praised for enhancing the naval combat experience.
• Engaging Naval Combat: Players find the naval battles to be enjoyable and impactful, with satisfying cannon effects and a good balance between RTS and personal control modes.
• Open World Exploration: The game includes an open world with treasure hunting and the ability to interact with hostile ports without immediate combat, which adds depth to gameplay.
• Affordability: Many users feel the price point is fair, especially considering the game's potential and the fact that it is developed by a solo developer.
• Developer Engagement: The developer is noted for being active in the community, responsive to feedback, and quick to release hotfixes, which is appreciated by players.

The main cons of the game

• Early Access Issues: Many reviews highlight that the game is still very much in development, with numerous bugs and incomplete features that detract from the overall experience.
• Land Combat Problems: Users report that land combat is janky, with poor animations and a lack of focus, indicating it is not the primary focus of the current development.
• Shallow Gameplay Mechanics: Some players feel that mechanics such as crew management and resource management are too simplistic or lacking, which may lead to a less immersive experience.
• UI and Sound Design: The user interface is described as bland and unpolished, while some sound elements (like music) are criticized for being discordant.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Crew and Resource Management: Users express a desire for more complex systems involving crew management, such as food and ammunition supply, to enhance immersion.
• Visual and Tactical Depth: Players want to see more detailed animations, such as crew members on deck during battles and visual damage on ships, to create a more engaging experience.
• Quest Variety and Difficulty: There are calls for more diverse and challenging quests, as well as the introduction of dynamic quest elements (like traps or deceptive quest givers) to add excitement and unpredictability.
• Improved UI and Accessibility: Suggestions for improving the user interface and providing better accessibility options, especially for visually impaired players, are common among reviews.

Summary

• Overall, while "Rise of Piracy" shows significant potential and has garnered a positive response for its core concepts and developer engagement, it is clear that it requires further development and polish to meet player expectations fully.

Summary generated on: February 25, 2026