We Are Football 2024

The main pros of the game

• Fresh Experience: Many users appreciate the game as a refreshing alternative to established titles like Football Manager, citing its engaging management mechanics and nostalgic elements reminiscent of classic football management games.
• Accessibility: The game is noted for being easy to pick up, making it suitable for both newcomers and casual players. The interface is praised for being user-friendly and less overwhelming compared to more complex simulations.
• Customization: The game offers extensive options for club customization, including the ability to create and manage clubs, design logos and kits, and even manage stadium facilities.
• Community Support: Users appreciate the availability of community mods and updates, which enhance the gaming experience by adding real teams, players, and other features.
• Fun Factor: Many players find the game enjoyable, especially with its mix of strategic depth and casual gameplay, allowing for quick season play.

The main cons of the game

• Unrealistic Match Simulation: A significant number of reviews highlight issues with the match engine, describing it as random and often leading to unrealistic outcomes where stronger teams lose to weaker opponents.
• Bugs and Glitches: Users report various bugs, including issues with player contracts, transfer negotiations, and game crashes, which detract from the overall experience.
• Limited Tactical Impact: Many players feel that tactical decisions have little to no effect on match outcomes, leading to frustration when trying to influence games.
• Long Loading Times: Some users express frustration over lengthy loading times, especially when simulating matches or navigating menus.
• Lack of Depth: While the game is accessible, some players criticize it for lacking the depth and complexity found in other management sims, particularly in player development and tactical options.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Improved Match Engine: Users desire a more realistic and dynamic match engine that accurately reflects player abilities and tactical changes.
• Enhanced Tactical Feedback: Many players want better feedback on how their tactical decisions impact match performance, including clearer indicators of player performance.
• More Realistic Transfer Market: The transfer market is seen as unrealistic, with players frequently making illogical moves or contract demands.
• Youth and Reserve Team Management: Players express a desire for deeper youth team development and more involvement in managing reserve squads.
• Multiplayer Mode: Some users wish for a multiplayer feature to compete against other players online.
• Additional Gameplay Mechanics: Suggestions include more detailed management of club finances, sponsorships, and the ability to influence player morale and team dynamics more effectively.

Conclusion

• In conclusion, while WE ARE FOOTBALL 2024 has been well-received for its accessibility and nostalgic elements, it faces criticism for its match simulation realism, bugs, and lack of depth compared to its competitors. Users express hope for future updates to address these issues and enhance the overall gaming experience.

Summary generated on: October 30, 2025