Casebook 1899: The Leipzig Murders

The main pros of the game

• Atmosphere and Setting: Many players appreciated the game's historical accuracy and the immersive setting of late 19th-century Leipzig, which added to the overall experience.
• Visuals: The retro pixel art style received positive feedback, with several users noting its nostalgic appeal and charm.
• Gameplay Mechanics: The deduction system, which allows players to gather clues and come to different conclusions, was praised. The combination of item collection, dialogue interactions, and deduction felt engaging for many players.
• Voice Acting: While opinions varied, some users found the German voice acting to be good and adding personality to the characters.
• Puzzle Variety: The game features a mix of puzzles that keep players engaged, with some users highlighting the challenge they provide.

The main cons of the game

• Gameplay Frustrations: A significant number of players expressed dissatisfaction with the game's resolution, particularly the final case, where players felt their deductions were ultimately meaningless or incorrect, leading to frustration.
• Puzzles: Several reviews noted that some puzzles were either too difficult or lacked clear logic, making them feel arbitrary or poorly integrated into the narrative.
• Length of the Game: The game is considered short, with only four cases, leaving some players wanting more content.
• Voice Acting Quality: While some enjoyed the voice acting, others found it lacking in professionalism, which detracted from immersion.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• More Cases: Players expressed a desire for additional cases or a longer game overall, as the four cases were seen as insufficient.
• Clearer Puzzle Guidance: Many users suggested that puzzles could benefit from clearer instructions or hints to guide players, especially for those who found some puzzles to be illogical or too challenging.
• Deeper Story Integration: Some reviewers felt that the historical setting didn't significantly impact the story, suggesting a need for a more meaningful connection between the narrative and the era in which it takes place.
• Improved Voice Acting: There were calls for better voice acting quality or more enthusiastic performances to enhance immersion.

Summary

• Overall, "Casebook 1899 - The Leipzig Murders" is viewed as a charming and nostalgic point-and-click adventure with a compelling atmosphere, but it faces criticism for its gameplay mechanics and length, along with a desire for more content and clearer puzzle guidance.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025