Old Skies

The main pros of the game

• Engaging Story: Many users praised the game's narrative, highlighting its depth, emotional impact, and clever exploration of themes related to time travel, loss, and personal growth.
• High Production Values: The game features beautiful hand-drawn art, a jazzy soundtrack, and top-notch voice acting, which enhance the overall experience.
• Character Development: Players found the characters relatable and well-developed, with strong performances that added to the immersion.
• Cohesive Writing: The writing is considered a standout feature, with many noting its quality and the way it weaves together multiple storylines.
• Intuitive Puzzles: While the puzzles are not overly challenging, they are well-integrated into the story, allowing players to progress without feeling stuck.

The main cons of the game

• Linear Gameplay: Some players felt the game was too linear and lacked the exploration aspects typical of classic point-and-click adventures. The puzzles often felt straightforward and sometimes too easy.
• Abrupt Ending: A common critique was the game's ending, which some found rushed or unsatisfying, feeling that it did not provide a strong resolution to the narrative.
• Inconsistent Art Style: While the backgrounds received praise, some players were less impressed with the character designs, finding them less appealing compared to the pixel art of previous Wadjet Eye games.
• Limited Replayability: Some users expressed that the game didn't offer significant choices that would alter the story, making it feel less rewarding to replay.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Complex Puzzles: Players noted a desire for more challenging puzzles that would require deeper thought and exploration, reminiscent of classic adventure games.
• More Agency: Some users wished for a greater sense of agency in decision-making, feeling that the narrative's direction was too predetermined.
• Expanded World-Building: A few reviews mentioned that the game could have benefited from more detailed world-building, especially regarding the implications of time travel and its effects on society.
• Diverse Character Interactions: There were calls for more varied interactions with NPCs, as some felt that characters were often one-dimensional or not fully explored.

Summary

• Overall, Old Skies is seen as a well-crafted addition to the Wadjet Eye catalog, celebrated for its storytelling and production quality, but with some critiques regarding gameplay depth and narrative resolution.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025