Shadowgate 2

The main pros of the game

• Puzzles: Many users appreciated the puzzle design, noting that they are challenging and logical, encouraging exploration and experimentation.
• Lore and Storytelling: Some players enjoyed the return of lore from the Shadowgate series and the thematic elements involving time travel and magic.
• Voice Acting and Sound Design: The voice acting, particularly from the character Yorick, received praise, and the soundtrack was noted as effective in creating atmosphere.
• Nostalgic Elements: Longtime fans of the series found some charm in revisiting the Shadowgate universe, despite the game's flaws.

The main cons of the game

• Game-Breaking Bugs: Numerous reviews highlighted severe bugs that can lock players out of progression, rendering the game unplayable at times.
• Combat System: The turn-based combat was criticized for being simplistic, repetitive, and lacking strategic depth, often devolving into trial and error.
• Graphics and Presentation: Many users found the 3D graphics to be poorly executed, with flat textures and a lack of detail, leading to a less immersive experience.
• Interface Issues: The user interface was described as clumsy and frustrating, detracting from the overall gameplay experience.
• Inconsistent Pacing and Narrative: The narrative was seen as disjointed, with character development lacking depth and pacing issues that hindered engagement.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Quality Control: Players noted a significant lack of polish and quality assurance, suggesting that the game felt rushed and unfinished.
• Engaging Combat Mechanics: Users expressed a desire for more depth and variety in the combat system, which currently feels uninspired and overly simplistic.
• Atmospheric Immersion: Many felt that the game failed to capture the eerie atmosphere and sense of danger that characterized previous entries in the series.
• Meaningful Interactions: The interaction mechanics were criticized for being overly simplistic, with players wanting more complexity and engagement in solving puzzles and exploring the environment.
• Character Development: Users wanted deeper character arcs and emotional engagement with the protagonist and supporting characters, particularly in relation to the game's lore.

Summary

• Overall, while Shadowgate 2 has potential and some redeeming qualities, it is marred by technical issues, a lack of polish, and gameplay mechanics that do not live up to the expectations set by its predecessors.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025