1428: Shadows over Silesia

The main pros of the game

• Unique Setting: The game is set in a historical context during a tumultuous period in Medieval Europe, which is a refreshing change from typical high-fantasy settings.
• Engaging Story: Many players appreciate the narrative, which intertwines historical events with dark fantasy elements, and find the characters interesting and well-developed.
• Atmospheric Graphics: Some users noted that the lighting and ambiance create a moody atmosphere that enhances the overall experience.
• Puzzles and Interactivity: The game includes various puzzles and interactive elements, which can be engaging for players who enjoy problem-solving.
• Dialog Choices: Players have the opportunity to engage in detailed, voiced dialogues with multiple choices, adding depth to interactions.
• Stealth Mechanics: The game features stealth elements, which some players found enjoyable.

The main cons of the game

• Clunky Controls: Many reviews highlighted the awkward and outdated control scheme, which can make gameplay frustrating and difficult.
• Combat Issues: The combat system is often described as basic and clunky, with players frequently feeling that the mechanics are unresponsive or unfair.
• Poor User Interface: The UI has been criticized for being cumbersome and cluttered, detracting from the gameplay experience.
• Visual Quality: Some players commented on the graphics being subpar, likening them to older games rather than a modern title.
• Difficulty Balance: The game is perceived as overly difficult, with many players feeling that combat encounters are unfair and lead to frequent deaths.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Character Customization: Players expressed disappointment over the lack of character creation or customization options.
• Inconsistent Game Mechanics: Users noted that certain game mechanics, like interacting with objects while holding a weapon, feel inconsistent and unintuitive.
• Clear Instructions: There is a noted lack of guidance in the game, with many players feeling lost due to insufficient tutorials or explanations of mechanics.
• Inventory Management: The inventory system is criticized for being poorly designed, with no option to hide or organize items effectively.
• Variety in Gameplay: Some players felt that the game lacked variety, with certain mechanics (like climbing or horseback chases) being underutilized or poorly implemented.

Summary

• Overall, while 1428: Shadows over Silesia has potential and an intriguing setting, many players found the execution of its gameplay mechanics and controls to be significant drawbacks.

Summary generated on: November 21, 2025