1666: Amsterdam

The main pros of the game

• Atmosphere and Setting: The game features a captivating medieval gothic horror aesthetic with a richly detailed representation of 17th-century Amsterdam, which many players found immersive and visually appealing.
• Story and Lore: The narrative is intriguing, weaving together historical elements with supernatural themes, engaging players and keeping their interest.
• Unique Gameplay Mechanics: Players appreciated the ability to control both the main character, Noa, and her cat, Aaron, for exploration and puzzle-solving. The integration of magic and investigative elements added depth to the gameplay.
• Voice Acting and Soundtrack: Many reviews highlighted the quality of voice acting and the atmospheric music, which enhanced the overall experience.
• Potential for Growth: Despite its current state, many players see potential for improvement and are eager to see how the game develops through updates.

The main cons of the game

• Combat System: The combat mechanics are frequently criticized as clunky, repetitive, and lacking depth. Players expressed frustration with the basic attack and dodge mechanics, finding them unengaging and difficult to execute effectively.
• Performance Issues: Many users reported technical problems, including lag, stuttering, and crashes, particularly on certain platforms like the Steam Deck. Optimization remains a significant concern.
• Quest Guidance and Navigation: Players found the quest system vague, with unclear objectives and poor guidance, often leading to confusion and frustration during gameplay.
• NPC Behavior: The AI for NPCs was noted as inconsistent, with some characters behaving unrealistically or failing to react appropriately, which detracted from immersion.
• Translation Errors: Issues with language settings and inconsistent subtitles (switching between German and English) were highlighted as major drawbacks.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Improved Combat Mechanics: Players expressed a desire for more diverse combat options, including blocking and a wider array of spells, to make encounters more dynamic and enjoyable.
• Better Quest Tracking: A clearer system for tracking quests and objectives would enhance player experience and reduce frustration.
• Manual Save Options: Users wanted the ability to save manually rather than relying solely on auto-saves, especially given the punitive nature of dying in combat.
• Enhanced Movement Controls: Many reviews called for smoother controls, particularly when navigating as the cat or during parkour sequences, to improve overall fluidity in gameplay.
• Increased Variety in NPC Designs: Players suggested that more diverse character models and animations would enhance the sense of a living, breathing world.

Summary

• Overall, while 1666: Amsterdam has garnered a mix of excitement and criticism, players are hopeful that future updates will address the current shortcomings and fully realize the game’s potential.

Summary generated on: September 21, 2026