Firmament

The main pros of the game

• Visuals: Many users praised the stunning graphics and beautiful environments, noting that the game is visually impressive and immersive.
• Puzzles: Some players found the puzzles to be rewarding, with a mix of challenge and satisfaction upon completion. The innovative mechanics of the Adjunct tool were appreciated by certain users.
• Atmosphere: The game successfully creates an atmospheric experience that evokes feelings reminiscent of Cyan's previous titles like Myst and Riven.
• Exploration: Players enjoyed the exploration aspect and the sense of scale in the game, appreciating the unique themes of the different realms.

The main cons of the game

• Puzzle Design: A significant number of reviews criticized the puzzles as being tedious, clunky, and lacking the depth or cleverness found in earlier Cyan games. Many felt that the puzzles did not provide a sense of accomplishment.
• Storytelling: Users expressed disappointment with the story, describing it as vague, poorly delivered, and lacking the rich narrative depth that fans expect from Cyan games. The ending was particularly criticized for being predictable and not satisfying.
• Technical Issues: Numerous players reported bugs, including soft-locks, collision issues, and crashes. The game was described as "janky," with many experiencing frustrating gameplay interruptions.
• Gameplay Mechanics: Controls and mechanics, especially the Adjunct tool, were often seen as cumbersome and unintuitive. Players noted excessive backtracking and a lack of interactive elements in the world that diminished immersion.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Rich Story Elements: Many players missed the detailed lore, journals, and environmental storytelling that were hallmarks of previous Cyan titles. They felt that the game lacked the depth that would make the world feel alive.
• More Engaging Puzzles: Users expressed a desire for more complex and varied puzzles that required deeper thought and problem-solving skills, similar to those found in Myst and Riven.
• Improved Interaction: There was a call for more meaningful interactions within the environments, as many found the puzzles too reliant on manipulating machines without enough context or clues.
• Better Optimization: Players noted that the game could benefit from better optimization, particularly for VR, and expressed frustration with the performance issues that detracted from the overall experience.

Summary

• Overall, while "Firmament" has its visual and atmospheric strengths, many players felt it fell short in gameplay, narrative depth, and technical execution compared to Cyan's previous acclaimed titles.

Summary generated on: October 30, 2025