Keeper

The main pros of the game

• Visuals: The game is consistently praised for its stunning, painterly art style and vibrant color palette, with many users describing it as a moving painting or a work of art. The visuals are considered some of the best in gaming, with comparisons to renowned artists and films.
• Atmosphere: Players appreciate the immersive and whimsical atmosphere, which offers a unique and emotional experience without the need for dialogue. The game's ability to evoke feelings through visuals and sound is highlighted.
• Creative Concept: The idea of playing as a lighthouse in a surreal world alongside a bird companion is seen as imaginative and engaging. The narrative, delivered through environmental storytelling, resonates with many players.
• Exploration: The game encourages exploration and curiosity, allowing players to traverse a beautifully crafted world filled with hidden secrets and lore.
• Emotional Impact: Several reviews mention the emotional journey the game takes players on, with some expressing that they were moved to tears.

The main cons of the game

• Gameplay Simplicity: Many users note that the gameplay is simplistic, with light puzzles that are often too easy or repetitive. Some players feel that the game lacks depth in terms of challenge and engagement.
• Short Length: The game is described as short, typically taking around 4-6 hours to complete, leading some to feel that it does not offer sufficient value for its price.
• Fixed Camera Control: A common complaint is the lack of camera control, which some players feel detracts from the ability to fully appreciate the environments and navigate effectively.
• Performance Issues: Several reviews mention technical problems, including poor optimization leading to frame rate drops, especially on less powerful systems. The high system requirements are also criticized.
• Lack of Narrative Depth: While the visual storytelling is praised, some players feel the narrative lacks coherence or a compelling structure, making it feel more like an artistic showcase than a fully realized game.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• More Complex Puzzles: Players express a desire for more intricate and challenging puzzles that would provide a greater sense of accomplishment.
• Expanded Gameplay Mechanics: Some users wish for a broader range of gameplay mechanics to keep the experience fresh and engaging throughout.
• Camera Freedom: Many reviews suggest that allowing players more control over the camera would enhance the exploration experience and appreciation of the art.
• Longer Playtime: A common sentiment is that the game could benefit from additional content or longer gameplay to justify its price point.
• Better Audio Design: While the music is generally appreciated, some players feel that it lacks memorable themes or that the audio mixing could be improved.

Summary

• Overall, "Keeper" is celebrated for its artistic achievement and emotional resonance, though it faces criticism for its gameplay simplicity, length, and technical performance.

Summary generated on: November 3, 2025