Tell Me Why

The main pros of the game

• Visual Design: The game is praised for its stunning graphics and atmospheric visuals, particularly the depiction of the Alaskan wilderness.
• Storytelling: Many players appreciate the intense, well-written narrative that explores themes of family, identity, and trauma. The emotional depth and complexity of the characters, especially the representation of Tyler as a transgender man, receive positive feedback.
• Character Development: The main characters, Tyler and Alyson, are described as realistic and relatable, with their sibling bond being a central focus of the story.
• Voice Acting: The voice acting is noted for being solid and contributing to the overall immersive experience.
• Emotional Impact: The game evokes strong emotions and leaves players reflecting on its themes long after gameplay.

The main cons of the game

• Pacing Issues: Several reviews mention that the pacing is slow, which may deter players looking for a more action-oriented experience. Some players feel that the game drags at times.
• Limited Gameplay Mechanics: The supernatural bond between the twins, while interesting, is criticized for being underutilized and too scripted, lacking the freedom seen in other games by the same developer.
• Repetitive Puzzles: Some gameplay elements, particularly puzzles related to decoding a children’s storybook, are described as repetitive and not very engaging.
• Low Replay Value: Many users feel that the choices made during the game have limited consequences, reducing the incentive to replay it.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• More Varied Gameplay: Players expressed a desire for more interactive elements or mini-games to break up the narrative flow and enhance engagement.
• Deeper Character Exploration: Some reviews suggest that supporting characters could have been more fleshed out and involved in the story.
• Increased Narrative Consequences: Users wished for choices to have a more significant impact on the story, increasing the stakes and emotional weight of decisions.
• Improved Technical Performance: Technical issues, such as inconsistent frame rates and performance problems, were noted as detracting from the overall experience.

Summary

• Overall, "Tell Me Why" is recognized for its artistic storytelling and emotional depth, but it also faces criticism for pacing, limited gameplay mechanics, and technical performance issues.

Summary generated on: October 24, 2025