Age of Empires II: Definitive Edition - Return of Rome

The main pros of the game

• Quality of Life Improvements: The game incorporates modern mechanics from Age of Empires II, such as unit formations, gates, farm automation, and improved pathfinding, enhancing the overall gameplay experience.
• New Campaigns: The addition of three new campaigns (Trajan, Pyrrhus, and Sargon) is praised for their engaging narratives, voice acting, and innovative gameplay mechanics.
• Nostalgia Factor: For fans of the original Age of Empires, the game offers a nostalgic experience with familiar civilizations and gameplay, albeit with modern enhancements.
• New Civilization: The introduction of the Lac Viet civilization is a positive aspect, particularly for fans from Vietnam.
• Smooth Gameplay: Many players appreciated the improved graphics and smoother performance compared to the original Age of Empires.

The main cons of the game

• Limited Original Content: Many users expressed disappointment that only four of the original Age of Empires campaigns were ported over, feeling this was inadequate for the price.
• Graphics Quality Issues: Some reviews noted that the graphics quality is lower than that of Age of Empires I: Definitive Edition, with dated visuals and animations.
• Multiplayer Experience: The multiplayer scene is described as lacking, with many players unable to find matches, leading to a feeling of abandonment of the community.
• Gameplay Discrepancies: Some players feel that the integration of Age of Empires I content into the Age of Empires II engine resulted in inconsistent gameplay mechanics and balance issues.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Original Campaigns: Users noted the absence of many original Age of Empires campaigns, which they felt should have been included to provide a more comprehensive remaster.
• Classic Sounds and Music: There was a desire for the original sounds and music to be included, as they evoke nostalgia and enhance the experience.
• Improved AI and Balance: Some players criticized the AI's performance and the overall balance of gameplay, suggesting that the AI is not as competent as expected.
• Comprehensive Multiplayer Features: Many users highlighted the need for better matchmaking and ranking systems in multiplayer, as well as the ability to play with Age of Empires I players.

Summary

• Overall, while "Return of Rome" offers a blend of nostalgia and modern gameplay improvements, it faces criticism for its limited content, graphical issues, and multiplayer shortcomings.

Summary generated on: October 30, 2025