Pentiment

The main pros of the game

• Narrative Depth: Players appreciate the rich storytelling and character development, highlighting how choices significantly impact the narrative and character arcs.
• Art Style: The unique medieval manuscript-inspired art style is frequently praised for its beauty and fittingness to the game's theme.
• Historical Accuracy: The game is noted for its attention to historical detail, providing an immersive experience of life in 16th-century Bavaria.
• Characterization: The characters are well-developed and relatable, with players enjoying their complexity and the way they evolve throughout the game.
• Engagement: Many users find the game engaging and emotionally impactful, with some describing it as a profound experience that resonates long after playing.

The main cons of the game

• Time Pressure: Some players felt that the time constraints in the early acts created a frustrating sense of urgency, limiting exploration and interactions.
• Lack of Puzzles: While the narrative is strong, a few users noted the absence of significant puzzles, which might deter those looking for more interactive gameplay.
• Replayability Issues: Some reviewers expressed doubts about the game's replay value, feeling that the experience might not differ enough in subsequent playthroughs.
• Character Depth: A few players criticized the protagonist, Andreas, for lacking depth and not feeling impactful based on the player's choices.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Voice Acting: Several reviews suggested that voiceovers would enhance the game's experience, making it more immersive.
• Fast-Travel Options: Users noted the absence of fast-travel features, which made navigation cumbersome and detracted from the overall experience.
• Clearer Objectives: Some players found it challenging to locate objectives and navigate the map, indicating a need for clearer guidance.
• More Interactivity: A desire for more puzzles and interactive elements was expressed, as some players felt the game leaned too heavily on narrative at the expense of gameplay variety.

Summary

• Overall, "Pentiment" is celebrated for its storytelling, art, and historical context, while some gameplay mechanics and design choices received constructive criticism.

Summary generated on: October 9, 2025