Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden

The main pros of the game

• Engaging Story and Characters: Many users praised the game's narrative, highlighting its emotional depth and the complexity of the characters, particularly the relationship between the protagonists, Antea and Red. The moral dilemmas faced during the haunting cases were also well-received.
• Atmosphere and Visuals: The game was noted for its immersive atmosphere and impressive graphics, creating a compelling setting in a fictionalized 17th-century New England.
• Voice Acting: Users consistently mentioned the high quality of voice acting, which contributed significantly to the game's storytelling and character development.
• Replayability: The choices made throughout the game can lead to different endings, encouraging players to replay the game to explore alternate outcomes.

The main cons of the game

• Repetitive Gameplay: Many reviews pointed out that the combat becomes monotonous over time, with a lack of enemy variety and repetitive mechanics leading to a grindy experience.
• Backtracking and Navigation Issues: Players expressed frustration with the need to backtrack frequently, compounded by a limited fast travel system and confusing map layouts that made exploration tedious.
• Pacing Problems: Some users felt that the game dragged on, with certain quests and segments feeling unnecessarily lengthy, detracting from the overall experience.
• Combat Mechanics: While some enjoyed the combat, others found it clunky and lacking depth, particularly in comparison to other action RPGs.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Improved Combat Variety: Players desired more diverse enemy types and combat mechanics to keep battles engaging.
• Better Fast Travel Options: A more robust fast travel system was suggested to alleviate the frustration of backtracking.
• More Meaningful Choices: Some users felt that the moral choices did not have enough impact on the game world, making decisions feel less significant.
• Minimap or Enhanced Navigation Aids: Many players requested a minimap or better navigation tools to assist with exploration and reduce confusion.

Summary

• Overall, while Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden received praise for its story, atmosphere, and character development, it faced criticism for its repetitive gameplay and navigation issues. The game was seen as a solid effort from a AA studio, with potential for improvement in future titles.

Summary generated on: December 1, 2025