Mafia: Definitive Edition

The main pros of the game

• Faithful Remake: The game is a well-executed remake that stays true to the original while modernizing many aspects, particularly in storytelling and graphics.
• Strong Narrative: The story of Tommy Angelo is compelling, with well-developed characters and high-quality voice acting that enhances the cinematic experience.
• Visuals and Atmosphere: The graphics are stunning, effectively recreating the 1930s setting with detailed environments, impressive lighting, and atmospheric sound design.
• Gameplay Improvements: While some mechanics remain old-school, the driving and gunplay have seen enhancements, making for a more engaging experience overall.
• Short and Accessible: The game features a relatively short campaign (around 10-12 hours), making it suitable for players with limited time.

The main cons of the game

• Linear Structure: The game is quite linear, with limited opportunities for exploration outside of the main missions, which some players find restrictive.
• Driving Mechanics: While improved, the driving can still feel clunky and unresponsive at times, particularly in missions that require precision.
• Generic Combat: Gunplay is described as feeling less impactful compared to the original, with some players noting that shooting mechanics can feel outdated or unresponsive.
• Collectibles and Side Content: Many players found the collectibles to be excessive and tedious, and there is a lack of meaningful side missions, making the open world feel empty.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Enhanced Open World: Players expressed a desire for more interactive elements in the open world, such as the ability to enter buildings or engage in side activities beyond the main storyline.
• Improved NPC Variety: There are complaints about the lack of diversity among NPCs, which can break immersion due to repetitive character designs.
• Additional Radio Channels/Songs: Players noted that more variety in the in-game radio stations and songs would enhance the experience.
• More Dynamic Gameplay Mechanics: Suggestions for better combat mechanics and AI improvements were made, as players found the current systems to be somewhat basic and lacking depth.

Summary

• Overall, while Mafia: Definitive Edition has received praise for its storytelling and visual fidelity, it has also faced criticism for its linearity and certain gameplay mechanics that could benefit from further refinement.

Summary generated on: January 5, 2026