Fan compares Ghost of Yotei with 7-year-old Red Dead Redemption 2. Guess which one came out on top

Do all games really need perfect realism? RDR 2 shows it’s possible, but Ghost of Yotei proves it’s not necessary.

Olga Racinowska

Fan compares Ghost of Yotei with 7-year-old Red Dead Redemption 2. Guess which one came out on top, image source: Ghost of Yotei; Developer: Sucker Punch.
Fan compares Ghost of Yotei with 7-year-old Red Dead Redemption 2. Guess which one came out on top Source: Ghost of Yotei; Developer: Sucker Punch.

It’s official, Ghost of Yotei isn’t just gorgeous, it also serves up a killer revenge story in a classic open-world AAA package. Reviews are glowing, with the game sitting at 94% on OpenCritic (our reviewer gave it 9/10). But even though nearly everyone agrees it’s great, someone noticed there’s one thing Red Dead Redemption 2 still does better.

Ghost of Yotei and Red Dead Redemption 2 face off on ice

Sure, the views of Mount Yotei are incredible (so incredible that one player even claimed the real mountain), and jamming on the shamisen on a cloudy day is a total vibe. But have you noticed that one thing in Ghost of Yotei that just breaks immersion? Yes, I’m talking about Atsu’s superhuman skills when it comes to running across frozen lakes. You probably haven’t – I sure didn’t, not until I saw a post on X.

Source: X @GTAVI_Countdown

Someone on X compared the ice-walking animations in Ghost of Yotei to Red Dead Redemption 2. Rockstar’s obsession with detail really shows: Arthur Morgan struggles like any normal human on ice, wobbling a little, especially when he tries to stop running. Atsu, on the other hand, is totally unfazed by any silly laws of physics. Maybe she’s just fueled by the unstoppable power of revenge or something.

Make sure to check out our Ghost of Yotei guide, complete with an interactive map marking every collectible and important location.

If you’d like to stay updated with guides, news, and interesting facts from the gaming world, join our community on Google News. By following us, you’ll get regular updates on game releases, industry developments, and unique insights into your favorite titles.

But it does make you think, do we really need every tiny touch of realism in games? Or would we rather get great ones more often, say every five years like Ghost of Tsushima and Ghost of Yotei, instead of Rocstar’s thirteen (or even longer if GTA 6 gets delayed), even if a few small elements get skipped?

Source: Ghost of Yotei; Developer: Sucker Punch

The gaps between GTA games used to feel like a blink of an eye. Vice City and San Andreas launched just two years apart. Meanwhile, the first Red Dead Redemption came out in 2010, and we waited eight long years for the next one. So maybe while Rockstar is now all about polishing every last detail, Sucker Punch deserves some credit for delivering amazing games without making us wait forever, even if Atsu’s moves aren’t the most believable.

Ghost of Yotei

October 2, 2025

PlayStation
Rate It!
Like it?

0

Olga Racinowska

Author: Olga Racinowska

Been with gamepressure.com since 2019, mostly writing game guides but you can also find me geeking out about LEGO (huge collection, btw). Love RPGs and classic RTSs, also adore quirky indie games. Even with a ton of games, sometimes I just gotta fire up Harvest Moon, Stardew Valley, KOTOR, or Baldur's Gate 2 (Shadows of Amn, the OG, not that Throne of Bhaal stuff). When I'm not gaming, I'm probably painting miniatures or admiring my collection of retro consoles.

Harry Potter-style wizard school game reminds us it’s still alive. Yet fans keep asking if it’ll ever actually come out

Next
Harry Potter-style wizard school game reminds us it’s still alive. Yet fans keep asking if it’ll ever actually come out

How to get more luck in Plants Vs Brainrots. All methods to boost your character

Previous
How to get more luck in Plants Vs Brainrots. All methods to boost your character

Hot News

Brainteaser answers in Dispatch. Let’s solve his riddles

Brainteaser answers in Dispatch. Let’s solve his riddles

Brainteaser answers in Dispatch. Let’s solve his riddles
Which Mecha Man contains the bomb in Dispatch. Here’s how to complete Comically Yours

Which Mecha Man contains the bomb in Dispatch. Here’s how to complete Comically Yours

Which Mecha Man contains the bomb in Dispatch. Here’s how to complete Comically Yours
Which movie theater should we search first in Dispatch. Complete Theatrically Yours easily

Which movie theater should we search first in Dispatch. Complete Theatrically Yours easily

Which movie theater should we search first in Dispatch. Complete Theatrically Yours easily
Where to find Hollow Abode and Aureate Pavilion in Where Winds Meet. Navigation through Mistveil Forest has never been so easy

Where to find Hollow Abode and Aureate Pavilion in Where Winds Meet. Navigation through Mistveil Forest has never been so easy

Where to find Hollow Abode and Aureate Pavilion in Where Winds Meet. Navigation through Mistveil Forest has never been so easy
How to “Visit Unique Stashes” in BF6. Complete BR REDSEC challenge easily

How to “Visit Unique Stashes” in BF6. Complete BR REDSEC challenge easily

How to “Visit Unique Stashes” in BF6. Complete BR REDSEC challenge easily