A Plague Tale: Innocence

The main pros of the game

• Emotional Storytelling: The narrative is highly praised for its emotional depth and character development, particularly the bond between Amicia and Hugo. Players feel a strong connection to the characters and their struggles.
• Atmosphere and Visuals: The game creates a hauntingly beautiful medieval environment, with impressive graphics and sound design that enhance the overall experience. The depiction of the plague and the dark themes resonate well with players.
• Engaging Gameplay Mechanics: While primarily stealth-based, the game offers unique mechanics involving rats and environmental puzzles that keep the gameplay interesting, despite some repetitiveness.
• Character Development: The characters, particularly Amicia, are well-developed, and their arcs are compelling, making players invested in their journey.

The main cons of the game

• Repetitive Gameplay: Many players noted that the gameplay can become monotonous over time, particularly the stealth mechanics and puzzle-solving, which lack variety and challenge as the game progresses.
• Linear Structure: The game is very linear, which some players found limiting. The straightforward path can lead to a feeling of being railroaded through the story rather than exploring the world freely.
• Clunky Mechanics: Some users reported issues with controls and AI behavior, particularly in combat scenarios. The combat is seen as less engaging compared to the stealth elements.
• Bugs and Technical Issues: A few players experienced bugs that affected their gameplay, leading to frustration.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• More Character Depth for Side Characters: While Amicia and Hugo are well-developed, other characters lack depth and interaction, leaving players wanting more from the supporting cast.
• Greater Gameplay Variety: Players expressed a desire for more diverse gameplay mechanics and challenges, suggesting that the game could benefit from additional complexity in puzzles and combat.
• Difficulty Options: Some users felt that the game was too easy and would have appreciated options for increased difficulty or challenge.
• New Game Plus Mode: Several reviews mentioned the absence of a New Game Plus feature, which would allow players to replay the game with retained upgrades or abilities.

Summary

• Overall, "A Plague Tale: Innocence" is recognized as a strong narrative-driven game with emotional resonance and atmospheric design, though it has its share of gameplay and structural criticisms.

Summary generated on: October 8, 2025